SA human rights commission denounces decision to close public schools

In this July 6, 2020 file photo, a handful of concerned parents picket outside a South African school, calling for it to be shut due to Covid-19. President Cyril Ramaphosa said on July 23  the government had decided to close public schools for all by essential grades from July 27 until August 24. Photo: Thobile Mathonsi/African News Agency (ANA)
In this July 6, 2020 file photo, a handful of concerned parents picket outside a South African school, calling for it to be shut due to Covid-19. President Cyril Ramaphosa said on July 23 the government had decided to close public schools for all by essential grades from July 27 until August 24. Photo: Thobile Mathonsi/African News Agency (ANA)

JOHANNESBURG, July 24 (ANA) – The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) says the government’s decision to close public schools from Monday until late August will increase inequality since students from poor households will have no other options to continue learning, making them fall further behind those from wealthier families.

In a national address broadcast live on television on Thursday night, President Cyril Ramaphosa said cabinet had decided to close public schools for all but key grades from July 27 to August 24, to prevent them from becoming sites of aggressive Covid-19 transmissions as infections peak.

“It was difficult to find consensus on the best approach … Taking into account the views, cabinet has decided today that all public schools should take a break for the next four weeks,” he said.

In response, the SAHRC said effectively by August 24 over 10 million South African children, depending on the grade they were in, would have lost over 50 percent or 100 scheduled school days as a result of closures in response to the coronavirus.

“The commission’s view on the opening of schools is guided by the evidence provided by a range of researchers that point to the devastating consequences of children not being at school,” it said, listing among them increases in hunger and malnutrition. For many poor children, the meal they get at school constitutes a high percentage of the total food they receive daily.

Ramaphosa did say in his speech that the national school nutrition programme would continue to operate so that all learners or their parents could collect food directly from schools.

The rights commission said stopping learners from going to school also increased the risk of child abuse and mental health breakdowns with rising rates of depression and anxiety, and that children were also at high risk of being left home alone when their caregivers went to work.

“(It also) increases inequality since poorer learners and schools are least able to continue learning. Poorer children regress significantly in terms of reading and maths skills during extended absence from school,” the SAHRC added.

South Africa’s main opposition Democratic Alliance party has also slammed the government’s move, saying it had caved in to teachers unions who have been demanding that schools be shut, citing the risk of Covid-19 infections.

“President Ramaphosa has bent the knee to all-powerful teachers’ unions … who do not have the best interests of learners at heart …  President Ramaphosa is behaving like a ‘spectator president’, taking instructions from whichever powerful interest group threatens him more,” DA leader John Steenhuisen said. 

– African News Agency (ANA), Editing by Stella Mapenzauswa

ANA NEWS WIRE Disclaimer:
The African News Agency (ANA) is a news wire service and therefore subscribes to the highest standards of journalism as it relates to accuracy, fairness and impartiality.
ANA strives to provide accurate, well sourced and reliable information across Text, Images and Video. Where errors do appear, ANA will seek to correct these timeously and transparently.
The ANA platform also contains news and information from third party sources. ANA has sought to procure reliable content from trusted news sources but cannot be held responsible for the accuracy and opinions provided by such sources on the ANA platform or linked sites.
The content provided for on the ANA News Wire platform, both through the ANA news operation and via its third party sources, are for the sole use of authorised subscribers and partners. Unauthorised access to and usage of ANA content will be subject to legal steps. ANA reserves its rights in this regard.
ANA makes every effort to ensure that the website is up and running smoothly at all times, however ANA does not take responsibility for, and will not be held liable for times when the website is temporarily unavailable due to technical issues that are beyond our control.